Template:Letby dramatis personae: Difference between revisions

(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)

Line 4:

! Name !! Profession !! Field !! Interest !! Camp

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Andreas Marnerides |Consultant |Pathology | ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23628455.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-3---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 3, 2023.</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Andreas Marnerides |Consultant |Pathology | Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23628455.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-3---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 3, 2023.</ref>

{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Owen Arthurs |Professor |Radiology | ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness |N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Professor Owen Arthurs viewed radiographic images for Child M and said they could not support or refute an air embolus.”</ref>

{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Owen Arthurs |Professor |Radiology | Expert witness |P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Professor Owen Arthurs viewed radiographic images for Child M and said they could not support or refute an air embolus.”</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Sally Kinsey | Professor | Haematology | ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness |N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-63798909|Lucy Letby: Baby's catastrophic bleed not spontaneous, trial told}}, BBC, November 29, 2022. Per this report, Dr. Kinsey accepted in cross-examination that her findings did not assist with the cause of death, and that she had limited familiarity with air embolus. </ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Sally Kinsey | Professor | Haematology | Expert witness |P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-63798909|Lucy Letby: Baby's catastrophic bleed not spontaneous, trial told}}, BBC, November 29, 2022. Per this report, Dr. Kinsey accepted in cross-examination that her findings did not assist with the cause of death, and that she had limited familiarity with air embolus. </ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Peter Hindmarsh|Professor| Endocrinology| ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/lucy-letby-manchester-crown-court-university-college-london-hereford-b1062992.html?|Baby had dangerously low blood sugar levels over three days, Letby trial told}}, ''The Standard'', 24 February 2023.</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Peter Hindmarsh|Professor| Endocrinology| Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/lucy-letby-manchester-crown-court-university-college-london-hereford-b1062992.html?|Baby had dangerously low blood sugar levels over three days, Letby trial told}}, ''The Standard'', 24 February 2023.</ref>

{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Stavros Stivaros | Professor |Radiology|~~Prosecution expert~~ witness|N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Paediatric neuroradiologist Dr Stavros Stivaros provided agreed evidence in which he said Child M had shown signs of brain damage, likely caused by the collapse on April 9, 2016.”</ref>

{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Stavros Stivaros | Professor |Radiology|Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Paediatric neuroradiologist Dr Stavros Stivaros provided agreed evidence in which he said Child M had shown signs of brain damage, likely caused by the collapse on April 9, 2016.”</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Simon Kenney | Consultant | Paediatrics | ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness |N}}<ref>This may seem controversial, but in all the reports online there is no indication of what evidence he gave. It is not reported or mentioned in judgments or summing up. I am assuming, therefore, it was uncontroversial evidence, that may have admitted by consent as a witness statement and not cross-examined. Happy to be corrected.</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Simon Kenney | Consultant | Paediatrics | Expert witness |P}}<ref>This may seem controversial, but in all the reports online there is no indication of what evidence he gave. It is not reported or mentioned in judgments or summing up. I am assuming, therefore, it was uncontroversial evidence, that may have admitted by consent as a witness statement and not cross-examined. Happy to be corrected.</ref>

| Dr. Dewi Evans || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics || ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution

| Dr. Dewi Evans || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics || Expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution

| Dr. Sandie Bohin || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics|| ~~Prosecution expert~~ witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution

| Dr. Sandie Bohin || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics|| Expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Shoo Lee|Professor|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="Panel"> Member of [[Media:Shoo Lee Expert Panel.pdf|International Expert Panel]]</ref>

Line 28:

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Jane Hawdon|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2024-11-12/specialist-doctor-felt-misled-about-suspicion-over-baby-deaths|Specialist doctor ‘felt misled’ about suspicion over baby deaths, Lucy Letby inquiry hears}}, ITV, 12 November 2024. Dr. Hawdon’s contemporaneous review concluded that the deaths of Babies A, I, O and P – were “unexpected and unexplained.” Her evidence to the Thirlwall Inquiry was that she may have taken a different approach to her review if she knew of the consultants’ suspicions of murder.</ref>

{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | ~~Defence expert~~ witness|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence|My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>

{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | Expert witness<ref>Not called.</ref>|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence|My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Roger Norwich|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="KillerorCoincidence">{{pl|https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question?|Lucy Letby: killer or coincidence? Why some experts question the evidence}} ''Guardian'' 9 Jul 2024.</ref>

Line 86:

| Dr. Faye Skelton || Professor || Criminology || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence<ref name="ch5doc">{{pl|https://www.channel5.com/show/lucy-letby-the-new-evidence|Lucy Letby: The New Evidence}}, Channel 5, September 2024.</ref>

{{letbyexpert| Dr. Colin Morley|Professor|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|File on Four}}, BBC, 1 October 2024 </ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby ~~prosecution expert~~ ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby Expert ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Waney Squier|Consultant|Pathology|Independent|D}}<ref name="ch5doc"/>

{{letbyexpert|Dr. Matthew Orde |Consultant|Pathology|Independent|D}}

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 ! Name !! Profession !! Field !! Interest !! Camp
 {{aligntop}}
-{{letbyexpert|Dr. Andreas Marnerides |Consultant |Pathology | Prosecution expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23628455.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-3---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 3, 2023.</ref>
+{{letbyexpert|Dr. Andreas Marnerides |Consultant |Pathology | Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23628455.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-3---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 3, 2023.</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Owen Arthurs |Professor |Radiology | Prosecution expert witness |N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Professor Owen Arthurs viewed radiographic images for Child M and said they could not support or refute an air embolus.”</ref>
+{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Owen Arthurs |Professor |Radiology | Expert witness |P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Professor Owen Arthurs viewed radiographic images for Child M and said they could not support or refute an air embolus.”</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{letbyexpert|Dr. Sally Kinsey | Professor | Haematology |  Prosecution expert witness |N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-63798909|Lucy Letby: Baby's catastrophic bleed not spontaneous, trial told}}, BBC, November 29, 2022. Per this report, Dr. Kinsey accepted in cross-examination that her findings did not assist with the cause of death, and that she had limited familiarity with air embolus.  </ref>
+{{letbyexpert|Dr. Sally Kinsey | Professor | Haematology |  Expert witness |P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-63798909|Lucy Letby: Baby's catastrophic bleed not spontaneous, trial told}}, BBC, November 29, 2022. Per this report, Dr. Kinsey accepted in cross-examination that her findings did not assist with the cause of death, and that she had limited familiarity with air embolus.  </ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{letbyexpert|Dr. Peter Hindmarsh|Professor| Endocrinology| Prosecution expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/lucy-letby-manchester-crown-court-university-college-london-hereford-b1062992.html?|Baby had dangerously low blood sugar levels over three days, Letby trial told}}, ''The Standard'', 24 February 2023.</ref>
+{{letbyexpert|Dr. Peter Hindmarsh|Professor| Endocrinology| Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/lucy-letby-manchester-crown-court-university-college-london-hereford-b1062992.html?|Baby had dangerously low blood sugar levels over three days, Letby trial told}}, ''The Standard'', 24 February 2023.</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Stavros Stivaros | Professor |Radiology|Prosecution expert witness|N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Paediatric neuroradiologist Dr Stavros Stivaros provided agreed evidence in which he said Child M had shown signs of brain damage, likely caused by the collapse on April 9, 2016.”</ref>
+{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Stavros Stivaros | Professor |Radiology|Expert witness|P}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23636819.recap-lucy-letby-trial-july-6---judges-summing/|Lucy Letby Trial recap}}, ''Chester Standard'', July 6, 2023: “Paediatric neuroradiologist Dr Stavros Stivaros provided agreed evidence in which he said Child M had shown signs of brain damage, likely caused by the collapse on April 9, 2016.”</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{letbyexpert|Dr. Simon Kenney | Consultant | Paediatrics | Prosecution expert witness |N}}<ref>This may seem controversial, but in all the reports online there is no indication of what evidence he gave. It is not reported or mentioned in judgments or summing up. I am assuming, therefore, it was uncontroversial evidence, that may have admitted by consent as a witness statement and not cross-examined. Happy to be corrected.</ref>
+{{letbyexpert|Dr. Simon Kenney | Consultant | Paediatrics | Expert witness |P}}<ref>This may seem controversial, but in all the reports online there is no indication of what evidence he gave. It is not reported or mentioned in judgments or summing up. I am assuming, therefore, it was uncontroversial evidence, that may have admitted by consent as a witness statement and not cross-examined. Happy to be corrected.</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-| Dr. Dewi Evans || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics || Prosecution expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution
+| Dr. Dewi Evans || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics || Expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution
 {{aligntop}}
-| Dr. Sandie Bohin || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics|| Prosecution expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution
+| Dr. Sandie Bohin || Medical Doctor || Paediatrics|| Expert witness {{cellpink}} Prosecution
 {{Aligntop}}
 {{letbyexpert|Dr. Shoo Lee|Professor|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="Panel"> Member of [[Media:Shoo Lee Expert Panel.pdf|International Expert Panel]]</ref>
@@ Line 28: / Line 28: @@
 {{letbyexpert|Dr. Jane Hawdon|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|N}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2024-11-12/specialist-doctor-felt-misled-about-suspicion-over-baby-deaths|Specialist doctor ‘felt misled’ about suspicion over baby deaths, Lucy Letby inquiry hears}}, ITV, 12 November 2024. Dr. Hawdon’s contemporaneous review concluded that the deaths of Babies A, I, O and P – were “unexpected and unexplained.” Her evidence to the Thirlwall Inquiry was that she may have taken a different approach to her review if she knew of the consultants’ suspicions of murder.</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
-{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | Defence expert witness|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence|My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>
+{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | Expert witness<ref>Not called.</ref>|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence|My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>
 {{aligntop}}
 {{letbyexpert|Dr. Roger Norwich|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="KillerorCoincidence">{{pl|https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question?|Lucy Letby: killer or coincidence? Why some experts question the evidence}} ''Guardian'' 9 Jul 2024.</ref>
@@ Line 86: / Line 86: @@
 | Dr. Faye Skelton || Professor || Criminology || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence<ref name="ch5doc">{{pl|https://www.channel5.com/show/lucy-letby-the-new-evidence|Lucy Letby: The New Evidence}}, Channel 5, September 2024.</ref>
 {{letbyexpert| Dr. Colin Morley|Professor|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|File on Four}}, BBC, 1 October 2024 </ref>
-{{letbyexpert|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby prosecution expert ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>
+{{letbyexpert|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby Expert ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>
 {{letbyexpert|Dr. Waney Squier|Consultant|Pathology|Independent|D}}<ref name="ch5doc"/>
 {{letbyexpert|Dr. Matthew Orde |Consultant|Pathology|Independent|D}}