Template:Letby dramatis personae: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 34: Line 34:
{{expertdef|Dr. Jane Hawdon|Consultant|Neonatology|Neutral}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2024-11-12/specialist-doctor-felt-misled-about-suspicion-over-baby-deaths|Specialist doctor ‘felt misled’ about suspicion over baby deaths, Lucy Letby inquiry hears}}, ITV, 12 November 2024. Dr. Hawdon’s contemporaneous review concluded that the deaths of Babies A, I, O and P – were “unexpected and unexplained.” Her evidence to the Thirlwall Inquiry was that she may have taken a different approach to her review if she knew of the consultants’ suspicions of murder.</ref>  
{{expertdef|Dr. Jane Hawdon|Consultant|Neonatology|Neutral}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2024-11-12/specialist-doctor-felt-misled-about-suspicion-over-baby-deaths|Specialist doctor ‘felt misled’ about suspicion over baby deaths, Lucy Letby inquiry hears}}, ITV, 12 November 2024. Dr. Hawdon’s contemporaneous review concluded that the deaths of Babies A, I, O and P – were “unexpected and unexplained.” Her evidence to the Thirlwall Inquiry was that she may have taken a different approach to her review if she knew of the consultants’ suspicions of murder.</ref>  
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | Defence expert witness|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence||My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>   
{{letbyexpert| Dr. Michael Hall| Consultant | Neonatology | Defence expert witness|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240826095436/https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1940403/lucy-letby-innocent-expert-evidence|My evidence might have changed killer nurse Lucy Letby's trial}} ''Express'', August 26, 2024.</ref>   
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
{{expertdef|Dr. Roger Norwich|Consultant|Neonatology|Defence}}<ref name="KillerorCoincidence">{{pl|https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question?|Lucy Letby: killer or coincidence? Why some experts question the evidence}} ''Guardian'' 9 Jul 2024.</ref>
{{expertdef|Dr. Roger Norwich|Consultant|Neonatology|Defence}}<ref name="KillerorCoincidence">{{pl|https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question?|Lucy Letby: killer or coincidence? Why some experts question the evidence}} ''Guardian'' 9 Jul 2024.</ref>
Line 64: Line 64:
| Dr. Christian Yates|| Professor || Mathematical Biology|| Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence     
| Dr. Christian Yates|| Professor || Mathematical Biology|| Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence     
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
| Dr. Alan Wayne Jones|| Professor|| Forensic toxicology|| Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence 
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Alan Wayne Jones| Professor| Forensic toxicology|D}}<ref name="insulin"/>
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
| Dr. Peter Green|| Professor || Statistics|| Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence   
| Dr. Peter Green|| Professor || Statistics|| Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence   
Line 86: Line 86:
|Dr. Gillian Tully || Professor || Forensic Science || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence  
|Dr. Gillian Tully || Professor || Forensic Science || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence  
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
| Dr. Neil Aiton || Consultant ||Neonatology || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Neil Aiton|Consultant|Neonatology| Independent|D}}<ref - name="insulin">{{pl|https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SQ8sgUwerw8n5H_u-pRcHqJaxgqeef4K/view|Summary of Joint Expert Witness Report on Baby F and L}} .</ref>
{{aligntop}}
{{aligntop}}
{{letbyexpert|Lord Sumption| Supreme Court Judge|Criminal Law|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://t.co/UoV3lyjWpJ|Why I believe Lucy Letby is probably innocent}} ''Sunday Times'', March 30 2025.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Lord Sumption| Supreme Court Judge|Criminal Law|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://t.co/UoV3lyjWpJ|Why I believe Lucy Letby is probably innocent}} ''Sunday Times'', March 30 2025.</ref>
Line 92: Line 92:
| Dr. Faye Skelton || Professor || Criminology || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence<ref name="ch5doc">{{pl|https://www.channel5.com/show/lucy-letby-the-new-evidence|Lucy Letby: The New Evidence}}, Channel 5, September 2024.</ref>
| Dr. Faye Skelton || Professor || Criminology || Independent {{cellgreen}} Defence<ref name="ch5doc">{{pl|https://www.channel5.com/show/lucy-letby-the-new-evidence|Lucy Letby: The New Evidence}}, Channel 5, September 2024.</ref>
{{expertdef| Dr. Colin Morley|Professor|Neonatology|Defence}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|File on Four}}, BBC, 1 October 2024 </ref>
{{expertdef| Dr. Colin Morley|Professor|Neonatology|Defence}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|File on Four}}, BBC, 1 October 2024 </ref>
{{expertdef|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Defence}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby prosecution expert ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Richard Taylor|Consultant|Neonatology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/lucy-letby-legal-team-new-evidence-convictions-klzvwmcx2|Lucy Letby prosecution expert ‘changes mind’ over how babies died|}}, ''The Times'', December 16 2024</ref>
{{expertdef|Dr. Waney Squier|Consultant|Pathology|Defence}}<ref name="ch5doc"/>
{{expertdef|Dr. Waney Squier|Consultant|Pathology|Defence}}<ref name="ch5doc"/>
{{expertdef|Dr. Matthew Orde |Consultant|Pathology|Defence}}
{{expertdef|Dr. Matthew Orde |Consultant|Pathology|Defence}}
Line 105: Line 105:
{{Letbyexpert|Dr. John O’Quigley|Professor|Statistics|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00258024241242549|Suspected serial killers and unsuspected statistical blunders|}} ''Sage'', 1 April 2024.</ref>
{{Letbyexpert|Dr. John O’Quigley|Professor|Statistics|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00258024241242549|Suspected serial killers and unsuspected statistical blunders|}} ''Sage'', 1 April 2024.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Carola Vinuesa|Professor|Immunology|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://x.com/carovinuesa/status/1873702814335013013|Sample post on X.com}}, December 30, 2024</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Carola Vinuesa|Professor|Immunology|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://x.com/carovinuesa/status/1873702814335013013|Sample post on X.com}}, December 30, 2024</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Adel Ismail|Consultant|Endocrinology|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|Lucy Letby: Experts tell BBC about medical evidence concerns}} BBC, 1 October 2024.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Adel Ismail|Consultant|Endocrinology|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/><ref>{{pl|https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo|Lucy Letby: Experts tell BBC about medical evidence concerns}} BBC, 1 October 2024.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Adam King|Barrister|Criminal Law|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240723234635/https://unherd.com/2024/07/the-questions-haunting-the-lucy-letby-trial/|The flaws in the Lucy Letby case}}, ''Unherd'', July 24, 2024.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Adam King|Barrister|Criminal Law|Independent|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://web.archive.org/web/20240723234635/https://unherd.com/2024/07/the-questions-haunting-the-lucy-letby-trial/|The flaws in the Lucy Letby case}}, ''Unherd'', July 24, 2024.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Ivan Blumenthal|Consultant|Paediatrics|Former CoCH Employee|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.youtube.com/@ivanblumenthal|Thoughts About Lucy Letby Parts 1-3}}, February 12, 2025.</ref>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Ivan Blumenthal|Consultant|Paediatrics|Former CoCH Employee|D}}<ref>{{pl|https://www.youtube.com/@ivanblumenthal|Thoughts About Lucy Letby Parts 1-3}}, February 12, 2025.</ref>
Line 112: Line 112:
As regular readers know, “[[consistent with]]” is often used for heavy lifting, and Ms. Moritz asks a lot of it here, concluding — these are her, and not Professor Wolfsdorf’s, words — that:
As regular readers know, “[[consistent with]]” is often used for heavy lifting, and Ms. Moritz asks a lot of it here, concluding — these are her, and not Professor Wolfsdorf’s, words — that:
{{quote|“In other words, the surest conclusion we can draw from Baby L’s test result is that he was poisoned with insulin.”}} </ref>
{{quote|“In other words, the surest conclusion we can draw from Baby L’s test result is that he was poisoned with insulin.”}} </ref>
{{Letbyexpert|Dr. Charles Stanley|Professor|Paediatrics|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/>
{{letbyexpert|Dr. Hilde Wilkinson-Herbots|Associate Professor|Statistics|Independent|D}}<ref name="insulin"/>
|}
|}