MiFID v EMIR

The JC’s Reg and Leg resource™

Index: Click ᐅ to expand: Regulation Index: Click ᐅ to expand: Regulation Legislation

Tell me more Sign up for our newsletter — or just get in touch: for ½ a weekly 🍺 you get to consult JC. Ask about it here.

The two major pieces of regulation covering the European investment banking and trading worlds are MiFID — the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive and EMIR — the European Market Infrastructure Regulation.

It is easy to get them confused, as they somehow impact on a lot of the same material: securities, transactions, swaps, stuff like that. The best way of thinking about them is that MiFID is regulates financial services, and the people who offer them to the public, to make sure they are behaving themselves and not taking advantage of the poor misguided souls who buy and sell financial services and products, while EMIR is designed to regulate and protect the financial system itself and therefore is focussed on setting standards and ensuring safety rails are in place to avoid the concentration of market risk in the system.

MiFID came into force in 2007, and was conceived and enacted well before the global financial crisis, as part of the EU’s general development and harmonisation of its internal market. EMIR was a direct response to the financial crisis.

So, at a super high level, what is the difference between MiFID and EMIR?

Comparison between EMIR and MiFID
Aspect	EMIR	MiFID
Regulation Type	Regulation (implemented directly into EU law)	Directive (implemented through national legislation)
Objective	Mitigating systemic risk in OTC derivatives markets. Therefore this focuses on investment activity, whoever is doing it.	Harmonising EU financial markets regulation. Therefore this focuses on investment firms who are offering services to the public.
Regulator	European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA)	National Competent Authorities (NCAs)
Scope	Regulates how participants transact in OTC derivatives markets, in particular: Clearing: When they have to clear transactions across a central counterparty. Margin: When they have to post regulatory variation and initial margin. Reporting: What they have to report about their trades to trade repositories	Regulates how financial services businesses provide investment services and activities to customers Regulated activities: The Investment services and activities set out in Annex I section A of MiFID. Client categorisation: The “professional”, “elective professional” and other (generally regarded as “retail”) client categories set out in Annex II of MiFID. Best Execution: The best execution obligations set out in Article 27. Transaction reporting: Don’t ask me why, but transaction reporting to National competent authorities is handled by MiFID.

more on the differences between trade reporting and transaction reporting:

Difference between Trade Reporting and Transaction Reporting
Aspect	EMIR Trade Reporting	MIFID Transaction Reporting
Scope	Primarily for OTC derivatives markets that are regulated under EMIR	Applies to a wider range of financial instruments, including securities and bonds that are regulated under MiFID
Purpose	Enhance transparency, monitor systemic risk, enable oversight	Designed to ensure MiFID-regulated providers of financial services are behaving themselves. Therefore may detect market abuse (whether by the dealer or the customer — because dealers are meant to be monitoring their customers’ activity aren’t abusing the market, ensure market integrity, enhancing investor protection
Information Reported	Details of executed trades, parties involved, derivative type, notional value, price, date, time	Details of transactions, instrument traded, quantity, price, counterparties, date, time
Regulatory Application	Under regulations like EMIR	Under regulations like MiFID

While there are similarities in the types of information reported under EMIR and MiFID they have different focuses (foci?) and scope. EMIR’s reporting requirements are tailored to derivatives, while MiFID’s requirements cover a broader range of instruments and activities.