And/or: Difference between revisions

104 bytes added ,  18 December 2019
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{a|plainenglish|[[File:Andor.png|thumb|right|500px|for extra cosmological points, try the preferred EU formulation.]]}}
{{a|plainenglish|[[File:Andor.png|thumb|right|500px|for extra cosmological points, try the preferred EU formulation.]]}}
{{f|And/or}} is the [[mediocre lawyer|lawyer]]’s equivalent of a damp kipper handshake. Avoid it.
{{f|And/or}} is the [[mediocre lawyer|lawyer]]’s equivalent of a damp kipper handshake. Avoid it. There is no more obvious sign that a text is in need of a [[plain english]] reaming.


“{{f|And/or}}” ''means'' “{{f|or}}”, because “{{f|or}}” ''includes'' “{{f|and}}”.
“{{f|And/or}}” ''means'' “{{f|or}}”, because “{{f|or}}” ''includes'' “{{f|and}}”.
Line 14: Line 14:
:{{or}}
:{{or}}


 
===The and/or paradox===
Besides, [[and/or]] is not just ugly; it’s circular. It presents as a {{t|paradox}}, because of that {{tag|slash}}. Now the slash is not a part of idiomatic punctuation in the English language. It’s a decoration with no fixed grammatical meaning. To use a [[slash]] in legal writing is to confess that the ordinary, punctuated words of the English language have defeated you.
Besides, [[and/or]] is not just ugly; it’s circular. It presents as a {{t|paradox}}, because of that {{tag|slash}}. Now the slash is not a part of idiomatic punctuation in the English language. It’s a decoration with no fixed grammatical meaning. To use a [[slash]] in legal writing is to confess that the ordinary, punctuated words of the English language have defeated you.


Line 23: Line 23:
Go back to your draft and strike all examples, and we shall never speak of this again.
Go back to your draft and strike all examples, and we shall never speak of this again.


{{seealso}}
{{sa}}
*{{tag|profound ontological uncertainty}}
*{{tag|profound ontological uncertainty}}
{{plainenglish}}
{{plainenglish}}
{{c3|conjunction|Plain English|ISIA}}
{{c3|conjunction|Plain English|ISIA}}