Liability (for withholding) - ISDA Provision: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{isdaanat|2(d)(ii)}}
{{isdaanat|2(d)(ii)}}
It is hard to peer into the fevered mind of an [[ISDA ninja]] who came up with this provision to work out just what it is meant to do, and why. The best guess comes from our old friend, the tiresome [[FT book about derivatives]], who think it addresses the time where a Payer makes a payment gross, relying in [[good faith]] on a {{isdaprov|Payee Tax Representation}} that the {{isdaprov|Payee}} is entitled to receive gross, only to then find that the tax authority in question requires the {{isdaprov|Payer}} to make that payment net after all.  In this case the Payer can require the Payee to indemnify it for the payment, interest and penalties.
It is hard to peer into the fevered mind of an [[ISDA ninja]] who came up with this provision to work out just what it is meant to do, and why.  


This seems a stretch — the usually fulsome prose of the {{isdama}} neglects in this case to say anything about Payee Tax Representations, right or wrong, much less the Payer’s legitimate reliance on them. But on the other hand it is hard to think of a better explanation. So, go Paul C. Harding!!!
The best guess we’ve seen comes from our old friend, the tiresome [[FT book about derivatives]], whose learned author contends that it addresses the time where a {{isdaprov|Payer}} makes a payment gross, relying in [[good faith]] on a {{isdaprov|Payee Tax Representation}} that the {{isdaprov|Payee}} is entitled to receive gross, only to then find that the {{isdaprov|Tax}}ing authority in question requires the {{isdaprov|Payer}} to make that payment net, and account to it for the {{isdaprov|Tax}}, after all.  In this case the {{isdaprov|Payer}} can require the {{isdaprov|Payee}} to [[indemnify]] it for the payment, interest and penalties.
 
This seems a stretch — the usually fulsome<ref>Did I say fulsome? Tiresome.</ref> prose of the {{isdama}} neglects in this case to say anything about {{isdaprov|Payee Tax Representations}}, right or wrong, much less the {{isdaprov|Payer}}’s legitimate reliance on them. It seems to say if the [[Payer]], whether through blameless inadvertence or stupidity, neglects to account for a tax it was obliged to account for, the poor old Payee has to cover.
 
But on the other hand, it is hard to think of a better explanation. So, go [[FT book about derivatives|Paul C. Harding]]!!!