Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 99: Line 99:
!Linear
!Linear
!Complex
!Complex
|-
{{aligntop}}
|Tight
| Rowspan="2" |Tight
|Examples
|Examples
|Dams, power grids, rail transport, marine transport
|Dams, power grids, rail transport, marine transport
|Nuclear power plants, DNA, chemical plants, aircraft, space missions, BANKS
|Nuclear power plants, DNA, chemical plants, aircraft, space missions, BANKS
|-
{{aligntop}}
|
|Control method
|Control method
|'''Centralisation''': Best to deal with chain reactions, and best to deal with visible, expected linear reactions
|'''Centralisation''': Best to deal with chain reactions, and best to deal with visible, expected linear reactions
|'''Centralisation''': best to deal with chain reactions once they happen:  
|'''Centralisation''': best to deal with chain reactions once they happen:  
Local control: best to deal with non-linear reactions and unexpected events as they happen.  
Local control: best to deal with non-linear reactions and unexpected events as they happen.  
|-
{{aligntop}}
|Loose
|Rowspan="2" |Loose
|Examples
|Examples
|Manufacturing, single-purpose agencies
|Manufacturing, single-purpose agencies
|Mining, Research and development, multi-purpose agencies, universities
|Mining, Research and development, multi-purpose agencies, universities
|-
{{aligntop}}
|
|Control method
|Control method
|'''Centralisation or local control''': Few complex interactions; component failures create predictable results, and can be managed centrally.
|'''Centralisation or local control''': Few complex interactions; component failures create predictable results, and can be managed centrally.