Power structure: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 14: Line 14:


===“Power” as a pejorative term===
===“Power” as a pejorative term===
{{power versus strength quote}}
Power structures are a feature of Critical Theory critiques of — well — the western world, basically, but only when rendered in the “glass-half-empty” terms of the permanently malcontent. Sure, social hierarchies can be pernicious, but anyone who favours any form of communal organisation beyond flapping around in primordial sludge will concende they don’t ''have'' to be: they can be constructive, enabling, levers to prosperity and betterment.
Power structures are a feature of Critical Theory critiques of — well — the western world, basically, but only when rendered in the “glass-half-empty” terms of the permanently malcontent. Sure, social hierarchies can be pernicious, but anyone who favours any form of communal organisation beyond flapping around in primordial sludge will concende they don’t ''have'' to be: they can be constructive, enabling, levers to prosperity and betterment.


We wonder whether James Carse’s distinction between “power” and “strength” wouldn’t cast a less Hobbesian light here:
We wonder whether James Carse’s distinction between “power” and “strength” wouldn’t cast a less Hobbesian light here:
{{Quote|A powerful person is one who brings the past to an outcome, settling all its unresolved issues. A strong person is one who carries the past into the future, showing that none of its issues is capable of resolution. Power is concerned with what has already happened; strength with what has yet to happen. Power is finite in amount, strength cannot be measured because it is an opening and not a closing act. Power refers to the freedom persons have ''within'' limits, strength to the freedoms persons have ''with'' limits.
 
Power will always be restricted to a relatively small number of selected persons. Anyone can be strong.
:—{{author|James P. Carse}}, {{br|Finite and Infinite Games}}}}
===Frontiers, utopian anarchy and why [[this time is different|this time isn’t different]]===
===Frontiers, utopian anarchy and why [[this time is different|this time isn’t different]]===
Nascent power structures don’t have a steady state, and take a while to settle down, usually only settling into a format quite removed from the utopian aspiration that might have brought the common interest together in the first place.
Nascent power structures don’t have a steady state, and take a while to settle down, usually only settling into a format quite removed from the utopian aspiration that might have brought the common interest together in the first place.