Rocks of Ages: Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{review|Rocks of Ages: Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life|Stephen Jay Gould|R27WZ9OTS1WKCG|14 August 2007|A much better book than its detractors claim|}}
{{a|book review|}}{{br|Rocks of Ages: Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life}}<br>
{{author|Stephen Jay Gould}}<br>
''First reviewed on 14 August 2007''


If you’ve read any of the clutter of recent books on evolutionary science or popular atheism, you’ll know that {{author|Stephen Jay Gould}} - and particularly this book, {{br|Rocks of Ages}} comes with something of a health warning: Gould, despite great eminence and magisterial publishing history, is seen by a certain clique of like-minded authors within the biological community as being damaged goods and this attempt at popular philosophy, with its central thesis of “Non-Overlapping Magisteria” (“NOMA”) - an attempt at peaceful mediation between science and religion - is given short shrift by such authors, and elsewhere tends to be put down to Gould’s compromised situation when he wrote it (terminally ill with cancer). Since his death a few years ago, Rocks of Ages has lost an able champion and as a result looks set to disappear quietly beneath the waves of the current, squally debate.
If you’ve read any of the clutter of recent books on evolutionary science or popular atheism, you’ll know that {{author|Stephen Jay Gould}} - and particularly this book, {{br|Rocks of Ages}} comes with something of a health warning: Gould, despite great eminence and magisterial publishing history, is seen by a certain clique of like-minded authors within the biological community as being damaged goods and this attempt at popular philosophy, with its central thesis of “Non-Overlapping Magisteria” (“NOMA”) - an attempt at peaceful mediation between science and religion - is given short shrift by such authors, and elsewhere tends to be put down to Gould’s compromised situation when he wrote it (terminally ill with cancer). Since his death a few years ago, Rocks of Ages has lost an able champion and as a result looks set to disappear quietly beneath the waves of the current, squally debate.