Template:Calculation agent dispute: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 10: Line 10:
'''The [[Dealer]]’s lawyer''': Look, dudes you seem to be missing the point. When we hedge, we are [[delta]] neutral. That means if our [[hedge]] pays 50, we pay you 50. So firstly, we can’t rip your face off.  
'''The [[Dealer]]’s lawyer''': Look, dudes you seem to be missing the point. When we hedge, we are [[delta]] neutral. That means if our [[hedge]] pays 50, we pay you 50. So firstly, we can’t rip your face off.  
*Secondly, we are owe you [[best execution]]<ref>Admittedly this only holds if the [[Dealer]] ''does'' owe best execution, but if it is {{tag|MiFID}}-regulated and you are a [[professional client]], it will.</ref>
*Secondly, we are owe you [[best execution]]<ref>Admittedly this only holds if the [[Dealer]] ''does'' owe best execution, but if it is {{tag|MiFID}}-regulated and you are a [[professional client]], it will.</ref>
*Thirdly, because we delta-one]] hedge, we come up with our {{eqderivprov|Determination Agent}} “determination” by actually selling the right number of shares. It isn’t like we confect some hypothetical valuation based on a model some geek in correlation trading built in [[excel]]. We don't go ask some stooge dealers for a soft estimate, and promise them champagne in the mail. We ''actually sell the stock''. Our own money out the door. We can't get it back. What you are asking is to second guess that trade by ''you''
*Thirdly, because we delta-one]] hedge, we come up with our {{eqderivprov|Determination Agent}} “determination” by actually selling the right number of shares. It isn’t like we confect some hypothetical valuation based on a model some geek in correlation trading built in [[excel]]. We don't go ask some stooge dealers for a soft estimate, and promise them champagne in the mail. We ''actually sell the stock''. Our own money out the door. We can't get it back. What you are asking is to second guess that actual transaction by ''you'' being able to appoint some stooge dealer for a soft estimate.
*Fourthly, there are a ton of controls on us already, both contractual and regulatory and economic:
*Contractual: The whole of Section {{eqderivprov|12.8}} is shot through with requirements to act in a [[commercially reasonable manner]], using {{eqderivprov|commercially reasonable procedures}}, going out to leading dealers and so on.