Legal services delivery: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 36: Line 36:
The ''content'' of legal services is entirely opaque to them. The actual law is — by the careful design of generations of nest-feathering<ref>Did I say “nest-feathering”? I meant “[[noble, fearless and brave]].”</ref> lawyers — baffling, long-winded and obtuse. It is quite incomprehensible to the management layer. Management must therefore take the lawyers at their word, and thus they must take the [[pizza]] as they find it it: whole, ineffable, immutable, and stuffed with odd things like artichoke, pineapple and anchovy:<ref>For the record: artichoke yes, anchovy, utterly. But ''pineapple'', a ''never''.</ref> basically,  an unsolvable brute fact of the universe. A manager cannot say “[[cross default]] is stupid” (though it is). She cannot say “you do not need that absurd [[indemnity]]; you would never use it, and a court would never enforce it,” however much these things may be true.
The ''content'' of legal services is entirely opaque to them. The actual law is — by the careful design of generations of nest-feathering<ref>Did I say “nest-feathering”? I meant “[[noble, fearless and brave]].”</ref> lawyers — baffling, long-winded and obtuse. It is quite incomprehensible to the management layer. Management must therefore take the lawyers at their word, and thus they must take the [[pizza]] as they find it it: whole, ineffable, immutable, and stuffed with odd things like artichoke, pineapple and anchovy:<ref>For the record: artichoke yes, anchovy, utterly. But ''pineapple'', a ''never''.</ref> basically,  an unsolvable brute fact of the universe. A manager cannot say “[[cross default]] is stupid” (though it is). She cannot say “you do not need that absurd [[indemnity]]; you would never use it, and a court would never enforce it,” however much these things may be true.


A manager knows that only one with magic powers can say those things. She can only focus on the things she can understand: how much it costs to hire such a person.  But there is a dark inversion to her ignorance. For such is the inscrutability of the legal craft — so impenetrable is this world — that all she can say is one has this magic, or one has not. Those who have it are interchangeable; substitutable; switchable; ''[[fungible]]''.
A manager knows that only [[Legal eagle|one with magic powers]] can say those things. A manager can only focus on the things she ''does'' understand: the ''price'' of such a person, not her ''value''.   
 
But there is a dark inversion to this ignorance. For such is the inscrutability of the legal craft — so ''impenetrable''  — that a manager knows only that one ''has'' this magic, or one ''has not''. Those who ''have'' it are interchangeable; substitutable; switchable; ''[[fungible]]''. Any of them will do and the cheapest is best. Hence the regular reconnaissance missions to those parts of Manila where the streets have no name.


===The irony of the ineffable===
===The irony of the ineffable===
Thus our manager arrives at the notion of ''delivery''. “I must have this ineffable magic,” she realises, “but it could be delivered from London, or Belfast, or Gdansk, a someone rifling through a [[playbook]] on his lap from a service centre on the outskirts of Hanoi.”
Thus, our manager arrives at the notion of ''delivery''. “I must have this ineffable magic,” she realises, “but it could be delivered from London, or Belfast, or Gdansk, a someone rifling through a [[playbook]] on his lap from a service centre on the outskirts of Hanoi.”


She cannot rationalise legal product, nor simplify it, nor cauterise it and expunge the [[tedium]] with which all legal product overflows — but she ''can'' parcel it up and outsource it. This is the tragic irony of the ineffability of the law.
She cannot rationalise legal product, nor simplify it, nor cauterise it and expunge the [[tedium]] with which all legal product overflows — but she ''can'' parcel it up and outsource it. This is the tragic irony of the ineffability of the law.