Template:Withholding and deduction pedantry: Difference between revisions
Amwelladmin (talk | contribs) Created page with "Happy news, readers: we have a report from the front lines in the battle between substance and form. The JC asked no lesser a tax ninja than {{plainlink|https://twitter.com/DanNeidle|Dan Neidle}} — quietly, the JC is a bit of a fan — the following question: {{quote|In the statement, “X may make a deduction or withholding from any payment for or on account of any tax” is there any difference between..." |
Amwelladmin (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
{{quote|I don’t think there’s a difference. Arguably it’s done for clarity, because people normally say “withholding tax” but technically there’s no such thing — it’s a deduction of income tax.}} | {{quote|I don’t think there’s a difference. Arguably it’s done for clarity, because people normally say “withholding tax” but technically there’s no such thing — it’s a deduction of income tax.}} | ||
Which is good enough for me. So all of that “shall be entitled to make a [[deduction or withholding]] from any payment which it makes pursuant to this agreement [[for or on account of]] any [[Tax]]” can be scattered to the four winds. | Which is good enough for me. So all of that “shall be entitled to make a [[deduction or withholding]] from any payment which it makes pursuant to this agreement [[for or on account of]] any [[Tax]]” can be scattered to the four winds. Henceforth the JC is going with: | ||
{{quote|X may deduct Tax from any payment it makes under this Agreement.}} | |||
Latest revision as of 14:50, 21 September 2023
Happy news, readers: we have a report from the front lines in the battle between substance and form. The JC asked no lesser a tax ninja than Dan Neidle — quietly, the JC is a bit of a fan — the following question:
In the statement, “X may make a deduction or withholding from any payment for or on account of any tax” is there any difference between “deducting” and “withholding”?
They seem to be exact synonyms.
Likewise, “for” vs. “on account of”?
We are pleased to report Mr N opined[1] replied:
I don’t think there’s a difference. Arguably it’s done for clarity, because people normally say “withholding tax” but technically there’s no such thing — it’s a deduction of income tax.
Which is good enough for me. So all of that “shall be entitled to make a deduction or withholding from any payment which it makes pursuant to this agreement for or on account of any Tax” can be scattered to the four winds. Henceforth the JC is going with:
X may deduct Tax from any payment it makes under this Agreement.