Ownership: Difference between revisions

From The Jolly Contrarian
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Where does one start? Well, not with Google’s definition, which fluffs it entirely.<ref>{{google2|define|ownership}}.</ref> “[[Ownership]]”, it says, is “the act, state, or right of [[possession|possessing]] something”. Well, only in the limited sense of the word possession — the sense in which it means ownership. So that’s a tautological definition. For it is quite possible to possess something one does not own: if I borrow your tennis racquet, I possess it, but you own it. I can possess your tennis racquet without it being my [[possession]], though — that is the limited sense, meaning [[ownership]].
Where does one start? Well, not with Google’s definition, which fluffs it entirely.<ref>{{google2|define|ownership}}.</ref> “[[Ownership]]”, it says, is “the act, state, or right of [[possession|possessing]] something”. Well, only in the limited sense of the word “possession” — the sense in which it means ownership. So that’s a tautological definition. For it is quite possible to possess something one does not own: if I borrow your tennis racquet, I possess it, but you own it. I can possess your tennis racquet without it being my [[possession]], though — that is the limited sense, meaning [[ownership]].
 
Merriam-Webster is [https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ownership not much better]. “Ownership” is “the state, relation, or fact of being an [[owner]].” We thank you for writing in.<ref>In fairness, the definition of [https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/owner owner] is a lot better: “a person who owns something; one who has the [[legal title|legal or rightful title]] to something; one to whom [[property]] belongs.”


In the legal sense, “ownership” is holding the [[legal title]] and the equitable [[Beneficial ownership|benefit]] of some [[property]] <ref>That is, an [[asset]] that is capable of being ''owned''.</ref> Not everything can be property: data that falls short of intellectual property, for example, and, arguable cash (being an abstract token of value and not a corporeal thing per se).
In the legal sense, “ownership” is holding the [[legal title]] and the equitable [[Beneficial ownership|benefit]] of some [[property]] <ref>That is, an [[asset]] that is capable of being ''owned''.</ref> Not everything can be property: data that falls short of intellectual property, for example, and, arguable cash (being an abstract token of value and not a corporeal thing per se).

Revision as of 15:05, 12 June 2019

Where does one start? Well, not with Google’s definition, which fluffs it entirely.[1]Ownership”, it says, is “the act, state, or right of possessing something”. Well, only in the limited sense of the word “possession” — the sense in which it means ownership. So that’s a tautological definition. For it is quite possible to possess something one does not own: if I borrow your tennis racquet, I possess it, but you own it. I can possess your tennis racquet without it being my possession, though — that is the limited sense, meaning ownership.

Merriam-Webster is not much better. “Ownership” is “the state, relation, or fact of being an owner.” We thank you for writing in.Cite error: Closing </ref> missing for <ref> tag Not everything can be property: data that falls short of intellectual property, for example, and, arguable cash (being an abstract token of value and not a corporeal thing per se).

Possession and ownership

Data, intellectual property and ownership

Cash and ownership

Beneficial ownership

References