Expenses - ISDA Provision: Difference between revisions

From The Jolly Contrarian
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(22 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{isdasnap|11|{{isdaprov|Expenses}} <br> A {{isdaprov|Defaulting Party}} will, on demand, indemnify and hold harmless the other party for and against all <br> reasonable out-of-pocket expenses, including legal fees and {{isdaprov|Stamp Tax}}, incurred by such other party by <br> reason of the enforcement and protection of its rights under this {{isdaprov|Agreement}} or any {{isdaprov|Credit Support Document}} <br> to which the {{isdaprov|Defaulting Party}} is a party or by reason of the early termination of any {{isdaprov|Transaction}}, including, <br> but not limited to, costs of collection. <br>|{{isdaprov|Expenses}} <br> A {{isdaprov|Defaulting Party}} will on demand indemnify and hold harmless the other party for and against all reasonable out-of- <br> pocket expenses, including legal fees, execution fees and {{isdaprov|Stamp Tax}}, incurred by such other party by reason of the <br> enforcement and protection of its rights under this {{isdaprov|Agreement}} or any {{isdaprov|Credit Support Document}} to which the <br> {{isdaprov|Defaulting Party}} is a party or by reason of the early termination of any {{isdaprov|Transaction}}, including, but not limited to, <br> costs of collection. <br>
{{nman|isda|2002|11}}
==Commentary==
Observers will note that, but for the odd comma, these two provisions are identical. And revolutionarily brief. Not that they couldn't be improved, of course; they just weren't.
 
The {{isdaprov|Expenses}} referred to in this provision would not be captured by the definition of "{{isdaprov|Close Out Amount}}" or "{{isdaprov|Early Termination Amount}}" because, qed, they arise only once that amount has been determined and the non-defaulting party is in the process of collecting it.
 
{{isdaanatomy}}

Latest revision as of 16:22, 14 August 2024

2002 ISDA Master Agreement

A Jolly Contrarian owner’s manual™

11 in a Nutshell

The JC’s Nutshell summary of this term has moved uptown to the subscription-only ninja tier. For the cost of ½ a weekly 🍺 you can get it here. Sign up at Substack. You can even ask questions! Ask about it here.

Original text

11 Expenses. A Defaulting Party will on demand indemnify and hold harmless the other party for and against all reasonable out-of-pocket expenses, including legal fees, execution fees and Stamp Tax, incurred by such other party by reason of the enforcement and protection of its rights under this Agreement or any Credit Support Document to which the Defaulting Party is a party or by reason of the early termination of any Transaction, including, but not limited to, costs of collection.

See ISDA Comparison for a comparison between the 1992 ISDA and the 2002 ISDA.
The Varieties of ISDA Experience
Subject 2002 (wikitext) 1992 (wikitext) 1987 (wikitext)
Preamble Pre Pre Pre
Interpretation 1 1 1
Obligns/Payment 2 2 2
Representations 3 3 3
Agreements 4 4 4
EODs & Term Events 5 Events of Default: FTPDBreachCSDMisrepDUSTCross DefaultBankruptcyMWA Termination Events: IllegalityFMTax EventTEUMCEUMATE 5 Events of Default: FTPDBreachCSDMisrepDUSTCross DefaultBankruptcyMWA Termination Events: IllegalityTax EventTEUMCEUMATE 5 Events of Default: FTPDBreachCSDMisrepDUSSCross DefaultBankruptcyMWA Termination Events: IllegalityTax EventTEUMCEUM
Early Termination 6 Early Termination: ET right on EODET right on TEEffect of DesignationCalculations; Payment DatePayments on ETSet-off 6 Early Termination: ET right on EODET right on TEEffect of DesignationCalculationsPayments on ETSet-off 6 Early Termination: ET right on EODET right on TEEffect of DesignationCalculationsPayments on ET
Transfer 7 7 7
Contractual Currency 8 8 8
Miscellaneous 9 9 9
Offices; Multibranch Parties 10 10 10
Expenses 11 11 11
Notices 12 12 12
Governing Law 13 13 13
Definitions 14 14 14
Schedule Schedule Schedule Schedule
Termination Provisions Part 1 Part 1 Part 1
Tax Representations Part 2 Part 2 Part 2
Documents for Delivery Part 3 Part 3 Part 3
Miscellaneous Part 4 Part 4 Part 4
Other Provisions Part 5 Part 5 Part 5

Resources and Navigation

Index: Click to expand:

Comparisons

Observers will note that, but for the odd comma, Section 11 in the 1992 ISDA and the 2002 ISDA are identical. And deliciously brief. Not that they couldn’t be improved, of course; they just weren’t.

Basics

An indemnity is all very well ...

Bear in mind, also, that your operating theory here is that your counterparty is a Defaulting Party — i.e., for all intents and purposes, broke. So while it’s a fine thing, this indemnity might not be of much practical use.

Is it covered in the close-out calculation?

No. The “Expenses” referred to in this provision would not be captured by the definition of “Close-out Amount[1] or “Early Termination Amount” because, Q.E.D., they arise only once that amount has been determined and the Non-Defaulting Party is in the process of collecting it.

Stamp Tax and Section 4(e)

In the limited circumstance of default, this section modifies the arrangement for who pays Stamp Tax as set out in Section 4(e) (which says it is the person whose tax residence precipitates it).

Premium content
Here the free bit runs out. Subscribers click 👉 here. New readers sign up 👉 here and, for ½ a weekly 🍺 go full ninja about all these juicy topics👇
  • JC’s “nutshell” summary of the clause
  • Background reading and long-form essays
    • Difference between Events of Default and Termination Events when it comes to Expenses
    • Is it covered in the close-out calculation
    • A limited modification to stamp tax arrangements

See also

References

  1. Or its 1992 equivalent, “the amount determined following early termination of a Terminated Transaction”.