The Infinite Game

The Jolly Contrarian’s book review service™ →Go uptown The Infinite Game by Simon Sinek Index: Click ᐅ to expand: Book reviews Tell me more Sign up for our newsletter — or just get in touch: for ½ a weekly 🍺 you get to consult JC. Ask about it here.

The JC is indebted to TED-talker extraordinaire Simon Sinek for the TED talk which introduced him to James P. Carse’s obscure but brilliant book Finite and Infinite Games, which provides the basic idea for this, Sinek’s own take on the subject.

Alas, “basic” idea, in more ways than one: Carse’s hypothesis is subtle, deep and many-splendoured. Its ideas continue to unfold on you, kind their own infinite game, months after you first ingest them.

Would that you could say the same about Sinek’s book. No such luck. Where Sinek understands Carse at all, he does so superficially and in a flat monochrome. But that isn't often. Mostly, Sinek misses Carse’s point altogether, and presents “finite mindsets” and “infinite mindsets” mutually-exclusive negative and positive moral values, and hence delivers a glib, lumpen social democratic tract, which is not Carse’s industry at all.

Sinek manages also to misrepresent Adam Smith, Shareholder capitalism, Evolution by natural selection, Friedrich Nietzsche and, most egregiously of all poor old Milton Friedman, whom Sinek paints as a kind of selfish Gorgon; something he emphatically was not.

Now Carse’s book is elegant but gnomic. It asks careful reading and, as you’d expect of an infinite game asks, the reader to work hard. But it rewards effort in a way that Sinek ’s superficial reading will not.

The greatest tragedy will be if Sinek Congress to wipe

Anecdotal, and ironically historical — it is very easy reconstruct an “infinite mindset” from a completed story. Not so easy to predict one.

“ to line a life of service”.

Pukesome moments

“if this book inspired you please pass it on to someone you would like to inspire”

Adam Grant