Minsky moment

The Devil’s Advocate™ The Jolly Contrarian holds forth™ →Go Premium Resources and Navigation In which the curmudgeonly old sod puts the world to rights. Index — Click ᐅ to expand: The Devil’s Advocate Index: Click ᐅ to expand: Essays

edit

Hyman Minsky’s “Minsky moment” comes at the end of a credit cycle which he sees as having five stages:

• Displacement: invention, war, change in economic policy:
• Boom: the invisible hand seeks and and exploits whatever opportunities are thrown up by the displacement (even bad displacements create opportunities: wars benefit the arms industry and the medical dressings industry)
• Euphoria: everything seems amazing, the world is picked out in vivid, sparkling light, awash with profit possibilities, and lending standards start to slide.
• Profit-taking: Smart people call the top of the market and sell
• Panic: Usually triggered by something dramatic or symbolic: the sudden failure of a hedge fund, or some such, everyone stampedes for the exits.

Minsky’s prescription is a little conjurer magic to temper the baser instincts of the invisible hand: “apt intervention and institutional structures are necessary for market economies to be successful.”

But still, the concept of the Minsky moment and, really, the whole five-stage credit cycle — still feels a little bit neat, convenient, and “survivor bias-y” — a story we might construct in hindsight to explain what the hell just happened, selecting suitable evidence for it as we go with the iron certainty of hindsight. Cycles, like waves, are not discrete, but operate on and in a bigger ocean with all kinds of cross-currents and perturbations — intersecting credit cycles of their own — making the market behave in unpredictable ways.

Premium content

Here the free bit runs out. Subscribers click 👉 here. New readers sign up 👉 here and, for ½ a weekly 🍺 go full ninja about all these juicy topics 👇

edit

See also

edit

References

[[category:Template:Devil Essay]] Hyman Minsky’s “Minksy moment” comes at the end of a credit cycle which he sees as having five stages:

• Displacement: investion, war, change in economic policy:
• Boom: the invisble hand seeks and and exploits whatever opportunities are thrown up by the displacement (even bad displacements create opportunities: wars benefit the arms industry and the medical dressings industry)
• Euphoria: everything seems amazing, the world is picked out in vivid, sparkling light, awash with profit possibilities, and lending standards start to slide.
• Profit-taking: Smart people call the top of the market and sell
• Panic: Usually triggered by something dramatic or symbolic: the sudden failure of a hedge fund, or some such, everyone stampedes for the exits.

This still feels a little bit “survivor bias-y” — a story we construct in hindsight and select evidence for it in hindsight. Cycles, like waves, are not discrete, but operate on a bigger, wider ocean with all kinds of cross-currents and perturbations making the market behave in unpredictable ways.

See also

• “The Minsky Moment”, John Cassidy, New Yorker, 27 January 2008