Equivalent - GMSLA Provision: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{gmslaanat|Equivalent}}
{{gmslaanat|Equivalent}}
Notice under {{gmslaprov|6.7}} is the notice required to participate in a corporate action.
“{{gmslaprov|Notice}}” under {{gmslaprov|6.7}} is the notice required to participate in a [[corporate action]].
This is a beast of a provision to parse. What I think it means in summary is this:
{{nuts|GMSLA|Equivalent}}


the key thing to observe is that “{{tag|equivalent}}" doesn't mean “of a similar type" or “broadly somewhat like the thing I gave you". It means THE EXACT SAME THING. Same [[cusip]]; same [[isin]]. Nothing else will do. The only distinction that “equivalent" permits is that the security does not have to be the precise security, down to the certificate number, that I gave you, as long as it is identical to and fungible with it.
This is a beast of a provision to parse. What I think it means in summary is set out in the panel to the right.


The reason for that is that a stock loan is a [[title transfer arrangement]]: since you are free to do with the stock I gave you as you please, you can (and probably will) sell it to someone else. So I can't very well expect you to give exactly the same item back to me. [[2.3 - GMSLA Provision|It's not a loan, after all]]. And actually if I were able to ask for the same item back, it would interfere with the legal characterisation of our {{tag|stock loan}} as a {{tag|title transfer}} arrangement.
The key thing to observe is that “{{tag|equivalent}}" doesn't mean “similar" or “somewhat like the thing I gave you". It means THE EXACT SAME THING. Same [[cusip]]; same [[isin]]. Fully [[fungible]]. Nothing else will do. The only distinction that “[[equivalent]]" permits is that the security does not have to be the precise security, down to the individual certificate number<ref>i.e., if it where a security-printed physical certificat form which, in  these enlightened, electronic, dematerialised times, it simply won't be.</ref>, that I gave you, as long as it is identical to and [[fungible]] with it.
 
The reason for that is that a [[stock loan]] is a [[title transfer arrangement]]: since you are free to do with the stock I gave you as you please, you can (and probably will) sell it to someone else. So I can't very well expect you to give exactly the same item back to me. [[2.3 - GMSLA Provision|It's not a loan, after all]]. And actually if I were able to ask for the same item back, it would interfere with the legal characterisation of our {{tag|stock loan}} as a {{tag|title transfer}} arrangement.
===GMSLA Equivalence===
===GMSLA Equivalence===
{{gmsla equivalence}}
{{gmsla equivalence}}


{{seealso}}
{{sa}}
*[[Fungible]]
*{{gmraprov|Equivalent}} in the {{gmra}}
*{{gmraprov|Equivalent}} in the {{gmra}}

Navigation menu