Gross negligence: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 7: Line 7:
After all, if you’re negligent, you’re negligent. It is hard to maintain your dignity against the complaint of an innocent, irate and out-of-pocket client by saying you’ve only been a ''bit'' negligent.
After all, if you’re negligent, you’re negligent. It is hard to maintain your dignity against the complaint of an innocent, irate and out-of-pocket client by saying you’ve only been a ''bit'' negligent.


A good way of looking at this is to put it in the language of the laity. Take the time-worn [[indemnity]] for costs, framed in usual legal ''kapusta'':
A good way of looking at this is to put it in the language of the laity. Like many other commonplaces of the ''[[Rechtsadler|Rechtsadlerkanon]]'', legal drafting can dress outright daftitude in sombre vestments. Take the time-worn [[indemnity]] for costs, framed in usual legal ''kapusta'':
{{quote|''You will indemnify us on demand for all extraordinary costs we incur in the absence of our [[negligence, fraud or wilful misconduct]].''}}
{{quote|''Customer hereby agrees to [[indemnify]] and keep indemnified Company on demand for all costs, beyond its ordinary costs of performance, that Company shall incur in the absence of aforesaid Company’s [[negligence, fraud or wilful misconduct]].''}}


It is easy enough to add some pepper to this cabbage:
It is easy enough to add some pepper to this cabbage:


{{quote|''You will indemnify us on demand for all extraordinary costs we incur in the absence of our [[Negligence, fraud or wilful misconduct|'''gross''' negligence, fraud or wilful misconduct.]]''}}
{{quote|''Customer hereby agrees to [[indemnify]] and keep indemnified Company on demand for all costs, beyond its ordinary costs of performance, that Company shall incur in the absence of aforesaid Company’s '''gross''' [[negligence, fraud or wilful misconduct]].''}}


But render this same idea in the elegant prose of those aboard [[Man on the Clapham Omnibus|Clapham omnibus]]:
But render this same idea in the elegant prose you find aboard [[Man on the Clapham Omnibus|Clapham omnibus]]:


{{quote|''You must [[reimburse]] us for extraordinary costs we incur, and could not [[reasonably]] avoid, when providing our services to you.''}}
{{quote|''You must [[reimburse]] us for any extraordinary costs we could not [[reasonably]] avoid when providing you our services.''}}


Now it is a bit harder to hide the weasel: not because it is harder to confect the grammar but because it sounds so preposterous when you do:
Now it is a bit harder to “hide the weasel” if you’ll indulge the expression: not because the grammar is challenging, but because it sounds so preposterous when you do:


{{quote|''You must [[reimburse]] us for extraordinary costs we incur, and could not avoid without being reckless, when providing our services to you.''}}
{{quote|''You must [[reimburse]] us for any extraordinary costs we could not, '''without being [[reckless]],''' avoid when providing you our services.''}}


===English law===
===English law===

Navigation menu